There are times when one person needs to be in charge and others when one doesn’t.
Understanding the difference can change everything.

When Dori and I bought our first boat, deciding who would run the boat wasn’t difficult. I came into our boating life with more experience, already having spent years on the water. I was comfortable making decisions about navigation, weather, docking, and the countless little challenges that come with cruising. It seemed perfectly natural that I would assume the role of captain.

What neither of us appreciated was that there are many times when being “captain” on a couple’s boat can be far more difficult than operating the boat.

On a commercial ship or naval vessel, the captain’s authority is clearly defined. Orders are expected to be followed, and everyone aboard understands the chain of command. A cruising boat couldn’t be more different. The person standing beside you isn’t a paid crew member. They’re your spouse, your closest friend, and your partner in every sense of the word. Long after the anchor is set and the engine is shut down, you’re still sharing dinner, planning tomorrow, and living together in a very small space.

That changes everything.

As much as we always tried to run the boat as a team, we quickly discovered that, in critical moments, there really can only be one captain. Entering a narrow inlet, docking in a crosswind, or making a weather decision offshore isn’t the time for debate. Conditions cannot be put on hold while couples negotiate. Someone has to evaluate the situation, make a decision, and everyone aboard needs to understand who that person is. 

The mistake many new captains make is believing that role continues long after the voyage is over. It doesn’t.

One of the hardest lessons for a new captain is learning to take off the captain’s hat the moment it is no longer needed. The authority that helps put a boat safely alongside a dock has no place deciding where we’ll spend the next week, whether we should stay another day because we enjoy a particular harbor, or how we’re going to spend our evening after the lines are tied.

The boat needs a captain. A marriage doesn’t.

That distinction sounds obvious until you spend months living aboard together, where the line between operating the boat and simply living on it becomes surprisingly blurred. Some days it feels as though every conversation involves a decision about weather, maintenance, route planning, provisioning, or schedules. It’s easy for the person carrying the responsibility of captain to slip into believing they’re responsible for every decision. I’ve learned that’s neither necessary nor healthy.

In fact, some of our best cruising decisions have come from conversations where Dori simply saw something I didn’t. She has a perception and insight that I sometimes lack. I tend to look at whether the boat is ready, at sea conditions, and our planned route. She often looks at us.

Are we tired? Have we been moving every day for the past week? Are we leaving because conditions are ideal, or because I feel like we should be making progress? Those are different questions, and over the years I’ve discovered they deserve just as much attention as the forecast. Experience teaches you how to handle a boat. Partnership teaches you how to handle your life aboard.

I’ve also discovered something else that surprised me. The most experienced person isn’t always the best captain.

Certainly, competence is non-negotiable. No one should be making decisions beyond their abilities. But once both people understand the fundamentals of operating the boat safely, experience begins to share the stage with qualities that are much harder to teach: patience, humility, the ability to stay calm when plans begin to unravel, and the willingness to listen before speaking.

I’ve known highly skilled boaters who became visibly flustered the moment something didn’t go according to plan. Their anxiety would spread through the boat faster than bad weather ever could. I’ve also known less experienced skippers whose calm demeanor made everyone aboard feel confident because they never allowed urgency to become panic. People don’t follow confidence because it’s loud. They follow it because it’s steady. Dori has taught me more about this than she probably realizes. She doesn’t need to raise her voice to make a point. On more than one occasion, she’s simply asked a quiet question that completely changed the way I was looking at a situation. Early in our cruising life, I may have heard those questions as challenges. Today I hear them coming from someone who cares enough about both of us to make sure we’ve thought everything through.

That’s not undermining a captain. That’s making one better.

Looking back over 14 years aboard Liberdade, I don’t think being captain has become less important. If anything, I’ve gained a deeper appreciation for the responsibility that comes with it. But I’ve also come to understand that protecting the boat and protecting the relationship are never competing responsibilities. They’re part of the same job.

The best captains don’t simply arrive safely—they create an atmosphere where everyone aboard feels respected, heard, and comfortable enough to speak when something doesn’t feel right. They understand that authority should be exercised sparingly, gratitude should be expressed often, and no successful voyage is ever the accomplishment of one person.

At the end of the day, no one remembers who gave the docking commands on a Tuesday afternoon in Beaufort or who decided to leave at first light to catch the outgoing tide. What we remember are the months and years we’ve spent together, the quiet anchorages, the shared sunsets, and the confidence that grew between us because we learned to trust one another.

I’ve come to believe that’s the real measure of a captain. Not whether they always make the right decision, but whether the person standing beside them still wants to go cruising with them tomorrow.

This article originally appeared in the November 2026 issue of Power & Motoryacht magazine.